psst...all games do this. They want to know how people play the game and what features never get used.

Are people genuinely just now waking up to practices that have been occurring for decades now?

Are we for real? Like I guess I'm glad but what the fuck?

When people like me brought this up a decade ago the line was "well they're tracking everyone who cares!".

“If you have nothing to hide, you have nothing to worry about! It’s for your safety”

I forgot about that one 🙄

Yea that works until someone decides what was legal yesterday, isn't today!

Wait, did Alex Barrientos samefag in 4chan‽

Click bait article. Games all have a toggle for this in the settings menu. Id bet money this game does too.

Man Claiming To Be Fired Rockstar Engineer Says GTA 6 Is Secretly Tracking Player Behavior and Reporting It to ~~Take-Two~~ NSA/CIA/FBI

This isn't really news, intricate tracking is in more or less all commercial software

Any game with online connectivity - and many without - collect a ridiculous amount of telemetry. Everything from how many bullets you fire, how many of them hit and missed, how long it took you complete an activity, and all sorts of other things.

This is exceedingly normal in modern game dev. Even indie games do this stuff. It's the primary way they figure out what is and isn't working, what needs to be patched, etc.

And if it's a game with any form of competitive play, they are not just sending that telemetry, they are packing it alongside critical game traffic so that you can't block the telemetry without disconnecting yourself from the game. Because it's all used in behavioral/heuristic cheat detection.

And it's not even done secretly. You literally agree to it in the EULA and often through a dedicated option for telemetry collection in settings. And all of it is visible with a non-invasive debugger, it sometimes even network traffic analysis

Not only is this normal, but big games often use this data as marketing. I remember after BG3 came out, their social media would occasionally post things like "4.2 million people romanced Shadowheart" or "18 million people pet the dog" or whatever.

Damn, I wonder if water is also wet??

No shit.

Damn near every game does that. Er... Reports player telemetry; they don't all necessarily go to Take Two. Maybe.

Yeah, I've been sending all my players data to take two. It's all thrown at taketwogames.com as a put request so they have all in real time I assume they know what to do with it

"I don't know what Take Two is gonna do with my Half-Life 1 play data, but they have it if they need it."

Secretly? Microsoft started doing this on the 360 and then Sony copied them. Achievements. They track what you do and when. It’s not a stretch to say they’re tracking other things. The capability is there.

Hell, Fallout 4 didn’t let you be evil at first because so many people in Fallout 3 did the good karma achievements first. They figured there wasn’t enough interest in evil play.

Lol, I think my first playthrough of FO3, I just did whatever anyone asked of me. Sure I'll blow up this city, sure I'll save this synth, sure I'll keep that one tree dude alive, sure I'll add the vurus to the water. My first character had no moral compass just was a yes man to the first person who asked him to do something for a quest.

Man, I gotta play more games like that it was a stupid playthrough.

My moral play throughs go like vibes -> good -> jerk responses only

The Donald route

You should go into politics, that's exactly the attitude that they look for.

I don't think you could have gta without that. It's literally a game based in large part on behavior tracking.

I don’t think you could have gta without that.

You will if you wait for the pirated PC copies...

Obviously? This data clearly can be sold. GTA is 100% a psyop. It’s also fun.

Isn't everything?

Oh good I gave up playing slop ass games and will always refuse to pay a $100 DOLLARS for a incomplete game. Even on PC you can rootkit dez nutz. Gaming is over for me. YOu can take that gipity GPU and shove it and that gipity ain't nothing but a poop sandwich. These companies hate their customers and developers. The epstains are in contol now. They can make it contentious but I will not bite that worm. This is not about woke vs hog it is about the epstain class and their pursuit of fishing for suckers. I hope eventually there is a opensource inde revolution. I will go back to 2D. If they take that then it is graphite and charcoal. Either way I wil survive. Some said god is dead well I say gaming is dead.... only for the fools and the richers. I will not fall for the good cop bad cop marketurd tricks. As soon as I smell sum bullshit I will pull out. Fomo is not strong with this one. 🖖 Like old is the new new and that goes across the board in these later stages. See capitalist innovation is a myth. Capitalist get inbetween what you want and need. They fart in your face and take your candy. 👶🍭. See I like to play games but I ain't no gamer. Gamers are the turds that escape reality and learn nothing... they don't really have any useful opionions about much ....They certainly don't care about the baby skull crushers and the children in GAZA. Gamers are losers. Learn a skill you fucking reprobates. The billionare farts in your face and I piss in your cornflakes. I love to seeing these turds cry.

Reviewer: "GTA 6 isn't even close to feeling finished. Bugs everywhere, unstable performance, random glitches, and somehow the game is struggling to maintain 30 FPS. After waiting this long, I expected a polished next-gen experience, not an expensive beta test.

And then there's Rockstar making a giant open-world crime game where apparently every possible interaction has to be approved by a committee. They give you a massive sandbox and then randomly decide what you're allowed and not allowed to do. Like bro, either give us a proper sandbox or stop calling it one

The devs spent years perfecting NPC hair, reflections, puddles, and someone's individual nostrils just for the game to run at 28 FPS while the NPCs teleport across the street."

Giant wall of text? Check.
Emojis? Check.
Medication? ....hmm

You know on balance I think you're probably better off taking the medication because all of this, this isn't healthy

Are you okay?

Literally every conspiracy theory going jump together and somehow the whole becomes even worse than some of its parts.

~~some~~ the sum of its parts

Technically also accurate

I was afraid of that with gta5. Sociologists and psychologist can do crazy stuff with that data too, back it against your Google or Apple data and see what kind of person you are, what kind of people are abusive or criminal assholes in their day to day.

Except no sociologist or psychologist would suggest that people act in video games the same way they do in real life.

If institutions took GTA behaviour as a serious benchmark of how people act in real life, they would be ringing the alarms about how half the population of the world are murderous psychopaths.

It's useful data to understand human behavior.

Not in the slightest.

It's also standard to collect data in video games. This isn't anything new, even if it's new to you. They use the data to see how people are playing the game so they can make adjustments in future patches/dlc

I never said it was new to me. Maybe its new to everyone else here that companies hire sociologists to study your and everyones behaviors from the data they collect.

Or maybe you guys are all just mean and like to talk down to people idfc.

How exactly is letting you know how they do use the information "mean"?

Talking down, with a know it all attitude like im an idiot is mean bro. That's what you and several other jumped at the chance to do. Idfc though it's fine, you weren't be mean? ok sure I totally believe you. Very good, yes they do collect data to improve their games good job, thanks for telling me.

"You need to calm down. Jesus Christ . Take your meds."

See, that was talking down to you.

"They use the information for x and y.".
Is educating you on reality. Not talking down to you.

In what capacity? If I shoot a random NPC in the head what does that tell you about me as a person in the real world, how can you draw any conclusions from a game.

I don't really think you want to talk about this. It seems more like you wanted to join in with the bullying because I said something you don't like or understand.

Someone asks questions about Stormy's opinion.

"Help! I'm being bullied!"

You've clearly never experienced actual bullying. ❄️

You are simply wrong. There is no bullying going on. People are just pointing out how you are incorrect.

Live with it.

No they're not. They're talking about things, I'm not talking about, and acting like they work in a field, I work in. Like how anti vaxxers think they're smarter than scientists, because they're using "common sense," when actually they're just not very well versed on the topic.

Oh now you're a scientist that works in one of those fields? Lol ok

The way I behave in a game has very little bearing on the way I behave in actual life. Apart from anything else I can actually drive a car in real life.

OK, but no matter what you think, patterns emerge. And sociologists are doctorate level individuals who seek out patterns in that data.

Sociologists and psychologist can do crazy stuff with that data

Everyone knows that when you get a degree in psychology; a data science degree gets thrown in for free. With access to every companies data included.

I don't think people really understand what all sociologists get hired to do. If you think they're not working at top companies analyzing the data, that like Google and Apple collect on you, you're wrong.

I worked with one that was analyzing Twitter users and their comments about ms13. One at my university worked on a sentiment analysis project of reddit comments in the MGTOW sub.

I'm not the idiot here.

No one mentioned the term idiot until you did but that aside. There’s probably a difference between a company hiring a sociologist to analyse its own data or a university analysing a public viewable subreddit. Versus them magically taking data from Take2, comparing it against data from Apple/google and peoples criminal records.

What point are you trying to make? That GTA doesn't track your data? That your data isn't used, one way or another? That a sociologist can't be tasked with making connections between your gameplay data and what choices you made, and draw a profile of you, and similar players that also made the same choices as you? Why not? Why does this, well known phenomenon among all kinds of companies that operate in various tech fields, not seem plausible with Rockstar?

Did you just want to argue for the sake of arguing?

Here's a direct link to Rockstar where you can see some basic stats that are visble for any user who's curious about their GTA 5 online stats

And the following can be found in Rockstar's account Privacy Policy:

Categories of Information Collected

The type of information we collect depends on how you use the Services. Generally, we collect the following information:

We use information we collect for our business purposes, including to:

* Provide the Services

* Fulfill product orders and other requests, respond to your questions, and communicate with you

* Enhance and personalize your experience on the Services, including to recognize you, maintain your preferences and settings, connect you with other users and link to your third-party platform, gaming, and social networking accounts

* Provide technical and other support

* Review the use and operations of the Services, develop new products or services, and conduct analyses to enhance or improve our software, content, marketing, support, and Services

* Conduct internal marketing and demographic studies

* Address issues with the Services or other business needs

* To protect the safety, security and integrity of the Services, users and our business such as by protecting against and preventing violation of our terms and policies, including combating fraud, piracy, cheating, tampering, unauthorized transactions, claims, and other liabilities, and managing risk exposure

* Interact on your behalf with the third-party platform, gaming, and social networking accounts you connect with our Services

* Participate in other processing that we inform you about when you provide your information or when you consent to such processing

* As permitted or required by law

We use information we collect for commercial purposes, including to:

* Provide you and other users with customized content, targeted offers, and targeted advertising on the Services, via email and text message, or on other sites, mobile applications, or social media on behalf of Take-Two or our business partners

* Contact you with information and promotional materials

* Administer rewards, surveys, sweepstakes, contests, or other promotional activities or events sponsored or managed by us or our business partners

* Analyze our users, in combination with other data, to assess our user base and target marketing at other similar groups

What point are you trying to make? That GTA doesn't track your data? That your data isn't used, one way or another?

No and no.

That a sociologist can't be tasked with making connections between your gameplay data and what choices you made, and draw a profile of you, and similar players that also made the same choices as you?

This is not what the original comment implied.

back it against your Google or Apple data and see what kind of person you are, what kind of people are abusive or criminal assholes in their day to day

The original implied sociologist would somehow have access to these game analytics (let’s assume they work for Take2 to make this at least plausible), that at best, provides insight into gameplay as you mentioned. Additionally, that data could then be used with other information from google/apple or other companies, somehow. Finally, this could, somehow, be used to draw meaningful inferences about real life behaviour based on in game behaviour. Which at least require further access to something like your criminal records.

Why not? Why does this, well known phenomenon among all kinds of companies that operate in various tech fields, not seem plausible with Rockstar?

The implausibility isn’t the gathering of analytics or building a marketing profile for users of their service, which is common, it’s the multiple other things after it. Again, somehow gaining data from multiple different companies/sources and being able to use this as an ad-hoc precog service. This feels like a weird repackaging of “violent video games are making kids violent”.

Did you just want to argue for the sake of arguing?

Did you? I did literally the same thing you’re doing here, which is giving my opinion on a topic.

"Ok"

LMAO! Good. Serves the assholes right.

midwest.social

Rules

  1. No porn.
  2. No bigotry, hate speech.
  3. No ads / spamming.
  4. No conspiracies / QAnon / antivaxx sentiment
  5. No zionists
  6. No fascists

Chat Room

Matrix chat room: https://matrix.to/#/#midwestsociallemmy:matrix.org

Communities

Communities from our friends:

Donations

LiberaPay link: https://liberapay.com/seahorse