I'm an American, I've taken lots of public transportation in my life.

People don't like it because you have to see human shit. I mean actual, human feces.

People don't like it because odds are good you'll see someone's dick or asshole or an inevitably gross boob of some kind

People don't like it because it stinks, the smells are indescribably awful, especially in summer.

People don't like it because of preachers, Nation of Islam, and "performers" who abuse the trapped audience.

In short, people don't like it because people don't like unpleasant experiences. In USA, public transport is rife with them all; arguments, violence, bodily functions, and despair.

(my experiences are from NYC and New Jersey)

In USA, public transport is rife with them all;

Why is that though? Why in other countries people don't shit and preach in public transport?

Because we don’t fund it and the automotive industry has spent its entire existence trying to destroy it. So it’s inefficient, dirty, provides horrible service, and is constantly having its budgets slashed because in fact America hates poor people.

Edit: it’s the same sort of principal with public and private schools and neighborhoods in the U.S. If there aren’t rich people having to use it you guarantee it’s going to be an absolute shit show.

Where would she take the bus this weekend?

It is probably inconvient for any place she needs to go. Might even need to drive somewhere to catch the bus first, and then be limited by whay she's willing to carry on the bus. (And I don't know what you're supposed to do on the bus if you have a child of carseat age)

I take the train every day to work and I hate the bus.

Public transportation also just SUCKs everywhere here. Using it means not that you have to walk a little or your be a little late but you can loose like 4 hours of your day because of it. Some places are better granted but most aren't. Especially those in suburbia

Incredibly stupid post based on nothing but this rich guy's imagination but it's anti-american so it'll be the top post of the community this week

Anyone who wants to talk about American attitudes towards public transportation should probably separate the discussion about buses versus trains versus commuter rail. Each serves pretty different demographics.

Am in Germany, I don't dislike public transportation. I dislike the people using public transportation.

I "hate" American public transportation, not public transportation. The places where its done well is fine. I cannot ask my mom to take it because she literally lives nowhere near a bus stop. Because US public transportation is awful. Especially in the suburbs.

I had no trouble with taking the bus to work, it's how I was able to afford my first house. You save a lot of money not owning a car. The trouble is most town's are designed for cars, commerce centers are built near easy access like right off the highway. Bus networks were designed for a central downtown shopping area. Older small towns all had a "downtown" city center. The new suburbs don't have that

We hate...... Listen im all for the fuck america posts because, well, fuck america. But dont fucking act like we are all one group. Americans hate it because the poor use it? Who the fuck is the poor? Ohhh, other Americans? Americans love public transit, but hate using it because american politicians are owned (in part) by big auto, and see to it that public transit is shitty.

That being said how I view the South Eastern Pennsylvania Transportation Authority is probably different from how the bible belt views their public transit options. (Again, they probably hate it cause its shit cause their elected officials want it to be shit)

To be clear I am a poor American.

No, we hate the bus because it takes eight to thirty times as long to make a trip using public transit.

Like, there's a local plane trip (Sacramento to Salt Lake City) that takes an hour (in the air), but it takes a day by train. It's really sad, the state of local rail.

no , they hate it because its shit I'm not even American , Europeans are so narcissistic and Ego-centric they shit on every one with out realizing their own flaws

We hate the busses because they suck. Stops are inconveniently placed, don't come often, and are usually in bad condition

If the buses are convenient and clean, suburban moms will happily use them

They suck because government doesn't want to invest in poor people's infrastructure. Less-poor voters would object

No, they suck because there are too many asholes who don't know how or want to behave in public and have to trash public infrastructure. You don't see this kinda problem in societies that place value on being polite, orderly and respectful, e.g. in Japan.

they suck because nimbys don't want stops in their neighborhoods because they fear the homeless will use the increased bus access to crime their houses.

They suck because people in this country dont want to pay for anything that doesnt directly benefit them. Voting against new stop installations doesnt even get to happen.

I feel like a lot of suburban buses suck because the built environment around them makes it nearly impossible to provide any sort of good service without extreme cost. Commercial areas have large arterial roads that are unpleasant to be next to, with stores surrounded by twisty feeder roads and moats of parking. Which leaves a transit agency 2 ways to route their buses, and they both suck. Either go along the massive roads and make people walk across the entire parking lot (which takes a while and sucks for disabled people), or have the buses wind their way around the parking lots to get closer to the stores (which makes the buses way too slow and even less competitive with driving). Meanwhile cars often get access to fast freeways, but buses don’t take them because trying to route a local bus on a freeway means stops even farther away from businesses on the side of an on-ramp, or more winding routes. Similar story with residential, streets have twisting layouts or cul-de-sacs which makes buses slow, or buses run along arterials that are far away from the center of the neighborhoods and slow to walk to.

I feel like people can walk parking lots. You literally have to if you park there anyway.

Dumb argument. Try finding a suburb that HAS a bus system that can reasonably substitute for car travel.

Bigotry against the poor is real, but public-transportation hatred is mainly a result of the self-sustaining feedback loop it has with the fact that American public transportation is shit.

when i lived in texas, my apartment complex was twenty feet from the bus stop. i never felt luckier.

it took three transfers and forty five minutes to take the bus to work, or fifteen minutes to drive. i ended up driving. nowadays i'd take my etrike (it'd take about twenty five minutes). it was better than nothing though. only one transfer and half an hour to get to the airport.

I hate the bus because it'll take a minimum of 3x longer to get there.

I went to Washington DC and the metro was so amazing. There's a train line every 10 minutes. It was so effective that I hate everywhere else now.

6 minutes by car to get to work

If I want to take the bus, I have to walk 2 miles to the closest bus stop, wait for the bus which will HOPEFULLY be by within 20 minutes of the hour, if it shows up this time. It might skip this stop if it's behind far enough. Then I have to take the bus around town the opposite direction I need to go and ride for 45-60 minutes until I get to the transit station. There I wait until the top of the hour to ride another bus for 10-20 minutes to stop where I can board a second bus that will take me to the closest stop where I can walk another 10ish minutes to get to work.

Anywhere between 1.5hr and 3hrs to get to work.

Hilariously I know for a fact I can bike there in around 15 minutes, and walk in around 50ish minutes. But doing so is illegal due to the roads and highways between me and work.

"Land of the free" has never not been a joke to me.

I've only ever had 2 jobs in 20+years of working where a bus is even an option due to where I live not having busses, or the busses not going to other cities...

I would love nothing more than to sit back and get to work within 30 minutes of walking out the door without having to concentrate on driving. More rest? Yes please.

You don't hate the bus. You hate the crippled and underfunded transit system your city made. The one that is so poorly run that it convinces you that you never want transit.

Right. I don't hate the bus. I hate the real, actual bus we actually have.

I don't hate the imaginary wonderful bus we might somehow someday have in the future, maybe.

Potato potato

It's not, that's my point. Argue for better transit, not no transit. We should have the freedom to drive, or have fast reliable transit, or bike, or whatever else we want. We shouldnt be forced to drive.

This isnt an argument against public transport. Its an argument against the post's claim as to why folks hate it.

That is why I said potato potato. Because I don't hate the actual vehicle or the people on it. It's because it's part of a system that isn't as useful as it could be. If taking the bus was nearly as fast as driving I'd have no reason to hate it.

can i hate the actual people on it. or at least some of them? one in particular. she gave me a witches' curse like 25 years ago and now i can't win at tennis it has nothing to do with being terrible at tennis

No

Yup. Takes me about 30 minutes to get to work by car. If I took the bus, it would take 2 hours. That's assuming the busses are actually on time and they almost never are.

I don't hate riding public transit. I hate how ineffective our public transit system is

What you probably hate more than that is how spread out and low-density we are, which is what causes public transit not to be able to work properly.

there's this great medium density neighborhood right by the local train depot. i really want to move there. my favorite coffee cafe is there for one.

I wish medium mixed density would take over. Being able to have a few restaurants and little shops close by, ideally with shared public spaces would be awesome. And then you have enough density to run things like trams and busses that are frequent enough to be workable. Parking garages so when you do need to travel or go where you can't easily by public transport, they're still there and available. Greatly reducing personal transportation, making things more efficient, making things better - instead of massive parking lots everywhere, you could have landscaping and beautiful public spaces. And get everyone working remotely as much as possible - wont' work for many jobs, but for the ones it will, it improves productivity and health and happiness.

It truly is a dream.

Nah, even that can still work. No one wants to pay taxes for it. We had bussing that worked for children in this "not able to work properly" region. It can in fact work. It just requires taxes.

Yes but taxes require people and low density development doesn't really have those.

Well, first of all, school bussing is entirely different from urban/civic bussing. I mean, I don't even know where to go to continue the conversation because it's like..... so radically different. The only comparable thing would be a massive shared "get people from home to work" thing that went around every day, scheduled, picking people up and getting them to work. Which would be awesome, although a nightmare to set up and operate because at least the kids are going to jsut a few schools, whereas workers would be going all over.

School busses that work have absolutely zero to do with why metro bus systems struggle. They aren't apples and oranges, they're apples and a stapler.

"gods its so different i cant even explain it. I mean buses going from one location to another.... just... so different. Ugh, just, just i cant even"

Considering that I did explain it: Okay, so you're either willfully ignorant or trolling. Gotcha. Neither is a good look. No reason to continue with you.

Now imagine public transit system that isn't perpetually fucked up by private cars and the industry lobbying.

People here keep voting down things that'll help. Ironically, because it isn't great. The industry ain't lobbying the people. It's a catch-22 at this point.

This is why I love Seattle, or at least the places I go. From home to work, it’s 22 mins with walking by bus. If I drive, it’s 11 mins plus parking and getting out of the driveway time, so say 15 mins. But I need to pay $170/month for the parking garage. Meanwhile the bus is free with my work. And I can use that short time on the bus to browse Lemmy, catch up on work before getting into the office, or even playing my steam deck!

This guy is proudly from Los Angeles and NYC. He is the absolute last person I would ask about the 340 million people in the U.S.

I absolutely believe this about those cities. Those cities are far less than 10% of the population of the country.

Yeah let me ask the Netflix “How to get rich” guy about normal people! 🤮

For the record I have met assholes from long island who would scoff at taking public transit. A guy literally took taxis to work every day. I thought that was absolutely horrifying and took the subway.

I also saw suburban families on public transit in every city I lived in. This guy is so full of shit

NYC is probably the only US city that has a usable public transit system, over half of families don't even own a car. Long Island isn't part of NYC FYI, that's the suburbs, people from the suburbs are scared of public transit. That guys a dumbass, the LIRR is fine and probably faster than driving lol

Chicago. San Francisco.

If you want functional mass transit in the USA look at the world class cities in blue states.

the DC Metro was pretty nice 20 years ago

It’s shitty now? That’s such a shame, it was awesome when I lived there.

Part of the problem is that so many of us live in places where walking (to work, the store, etc) isn’t even a possibility, and public transportation is a joke the further you get away from large metropolitan centers. It’s as true for “suburbia” as it is for the exurbs and rural communities. The entire country is built around the almighty automobile. But OP’s point is still true, I guess.

Fun fact: In the U.S., suburbia was literally, deliberately engineered that way in order to keep poor people away. (Poor people being a useful proxy for black people after the Supreme Court ruled that overt housing discrimination by race was unconstitutional.)

Yeah but why is public transport not a possibility? From context I assume you're talking about the USA, and in the case of the USA individual-centric city planning has 100% been a choice and continues to be a choice.

Exactly. I love the idea of the bus and not having to drive but not the implementation.

I work in our state capital and live 6 miles away. I’m on a bus route. To catch the bus and take that to work would take me 1 hour. I could walk it in that time.

I could take a more direct bus but I’d have to drive to it for total travel to take less than an hour total.

Poor people in America aren't American somehow?

Buses around here only come once every hour, are frequently late, sometimes just completely cancel with no warning, take significantly longer to arrive than doing the same route by car, and often requiring walking multiple miles to reach your destination from the bus stop. The reason people hate buses is because the buses fucking suck.

But if more people took the bus, we'd have more busses.

It's a chicken and egg sort of situation.

Right now we have an unhealthy chicken, we can either get more chickens and we'll see more eggs. Or we can have eggs magically appear and more chickens show up

And the reason buses suck is because car manufacturers are financially interested in it staying that way.

Wait a minute, I rent and take the bus.

Oh. Right.

The belief is that buses are dangerous. The majority of my family members would list that as their #1 reason for never riding them.

There are some bus lines that actually are dangerous, most aren't.

These examples are terrible. Loads of Americans rent, for various reasons. The ones that hate it are the ones that don't have a choice because the market has become predatory.

Take the bus or walk both don't work for the same reason... A majority of our infrastructure is designed around personal automobiles.

It's genuinely dangerous to walk or bike in a lot of places DUE to cars.

The buses, if they do run in your area, are unreliable or don't cover times that make sense for you.

Mostly only rich people hate any of these things, and of course the rich hate poor people...

I didn't hate renting because it's "for poor people". I hate renting because I'm paying some asshole an absurd amount of money for their property.

They get the passive income and build equity while that money is gone for me.

Find a bus that goes through the suburbs. At my old house in the suburbs, you would have about an hour walk to the nearest public bus stop. Getting in or around a city sure that makes sense, but any other scenario and it just doesnt make sense.

Is he assuming that I have a suburban mom?

I lived in Columbus, Ohio a 2-minute walk from a bus stop. I bought a car because my drive to work was about 30 minutes and the drive home about an hour (there was some real traffic issues with every possible route and then rush hour). The bus would have taken me almost 3 hours each way with 30 to 40 minutes of that being walking. I was trying to avoid buying the car because I knew I'd be moving to Japan, but oh well.

midwest.social

Rules

  1. No porn.
  2. No bigotry, hate speech.
  3. No ads / spamming.
  4. No conspiracies / QAnon / antivaxx sentiment
  5. No zionists
  6. No fascists

Chat Room

Matrix chat room: https://matrix.to/#/#midwestsociallemmy:matrix.org

Communities

Communities from our friends:

Donations

LiberaPay link: https://liberapay.com/seahorse