318
Its best explained by this thread: https://mstdn.jp/@GrapheneOS@grapheneos.social/117645039420648634
TL:DR is that Google's business side is threatening to revoke android licenses from phones that support GOS and is likely planning to lock the bootloaders on Pixel phones going forward. Important to note is that in GOS own words, the actual Google Android team is seemingly not down with it and has helped GOS work on things like Vanadium. As it stands it seems like Graphene is trying to take legal action against Google.
Imagine pushing people to give your enemy money for a good decade and suddenly waking up to the enemy doing evil stuff.
\pikachu face
This is a problem, that is for certain.
Just keep in mind that Daniel is legitimately paranoid (part of why GOS is as secure as it is) and tends to lash out at others over....not a whole lot. There was a whole thing between Calyx and GOS last year over what amounted to be a big ol' nothingburger.
That said, I believe him here - Google is very clearly trying to clamp down on Android as a whole, and has been for some time now. Enshittification has taken root and worming its way in.
Guillotine related
A few years ago, this could have been another anti-trust.
Anyone have any experience daily driving this: https://denialwm.org/mobile
so how do we fork and take android away from google? what's the best course of action?
A hard fork of AOSP is possible now, but then you need a lot of devs, funding, time, and a project capable of maintaining everything with safeguards against being evil. I guess this means: you need money.
Just use AI /s
It's concerning that they provide no sources or evidence, and that all the comments asking for evidence and proof are not displayed on GrapheneOS's own Mastodon instance.
Original post: https://grapheneos.social/@GrapheneOS/117645038299496084
People asking for proof/evidence: https://masto.nyc/@fairusr/117646354356815046 https://infosec.exchange/@S1m/117648103379775497
No accusing them of censoring, just a concerning observation.
Yeah as a graphene user myself the devs do have a tendency to take very definitive stances without a lot of effort to justify it. They trade on their reputation a little much for my taste, but I still trust them much more than the alternatives.
Well I guess we gotta sue in europe for open bootloaders. Hell I'm down for it.
I want to write an Armend Miftari style "Thank you EU" song for your contributions to consumer protections.
Do you mean plans like the Free Software Foundation's Project.. LibrePhone? Please stay away from that. You guys here love backdoors so much that you use Google hardware or Snapdragon the Dragon, which snaps up all your data... Please stay away from LibrePhone, Purism Librem 5 etc! Stick to your backdoors on real-time operating systems ( QuRT)below Android... with all those CVEs... You guys love them so much!
I'm gonna be honest with you I have no idea what you're trying to tell me.
I speak obnoxious prick (i took an elective during my education years) , i'll translate for you.
Google Hardware and Snapdragon processors are bad and full of backdoors and security issues.
There is no possible reason, other than you being stupid, for using anything related to the above items.
By comparison the LibrePhone (by the free software foundation) and Librem 5 ( by purism ) have none of these issues.
That's a direct translation, I'm not declaring any of it to be correct, direct all your question to the OP.
I realize you don't understand that. You're already confusing privacy with security.
None of these words are in the bible.
Just like we are never going to beg MS into unfucking Windows, the same goes for Googles spyware platform.
Need to work towards a post Android future
- https://nura.eco/
- https://mobian-project.org/
- https://plasma-mobile.org/
- https://phosh.mobi/
- https://lemmy.ml/c/linuxphones
https://denialwm.org/mobile
The website seems AI-generated, already a bad sign.
My problem with GOS was always that it makes people buy google phones. It feels silly to get away from google by giving google money. Even buying second hand, makes it more attractive for people to buy new pixel phones.
I get the whole uber privacy focus, but that puts smaller manufacturers in a corner, where either they make a ridiculously expensive phone that has the hardware requirements for GOS, or an affordable phone with no GOS.
I am really happy with my Fairphone 6 with e/os. I like to support a smaller manufacturer that cares about fairness in its supply chain and long term affordable reparability. I know hardware wise, my phone isn't as secure as a pixel with GOS, but it's secure enough for me, and most important, private.
Hopefully many many years from now, when I do have to upgrade, I'll likely go with a Jolla phone next. But this is after my current phone is truly dead.
My problem with GOS was always that it makes people buy google phones. It feels silly to get away from google by giving google money. Even buying second hand, makes it more attractive for people to buy new pixel phones.
Been making this argument for years now and the GrapheneOS defenders don't give a single shit. I understand wanting to be secure or whatever, but how can you not see that giving Google money is 100% going to bite you in the ass?
This is explained pretty thoroughly on their FAQ.
https://grapheneos.org/faq#future-devices
TL;DR - Pixels have the hardware that meets Graphene's requirements, a bootloader that can be relocked with a custom signing key, and more.
My problem with GOS was always that it makes people buy google phones
You don't have to buy a new phone. My wife bought a used Pixel 9 Pro XL earlier this year specifically for Graphene.
Yeah graphene devs are cool but a little too hardcore for their own good sometimes. Most people don't want a privacy-bulletproof device, they just want something with minimal Google tracking. I have thought before they should consider a sort of "graphene lite" side project, but I dunno...
As grouchy and uptight as the GOS devs are, the whole point of GOS is to be as secure as possible.
If you want something lighter, then Lineage, /e/, CalyxOS, and others exist for that purpose.
Yeah exactly. Don't let the perfect be the enemy of the good. Luckily there are alternatives.
It's about being able to re-lock the bootloader, not expensive hardware requirements
I believe that it is specifically about being about to re-lock the bootloader with a custom key. That still wouldn't be expensive to do, but almost no one offers it.
If that were the case, they would support the Fairphone 6 and a lot of other phones. I locked my bootloader after installing e/os.
Been thinking about getting the fairphone 6+, what are the pros and cons you've seen ysing it. and what do you think of it's privacy features?
So, by default the FP6(+) comes with regular android. You can either flash e/os yourself (really easy with a browser based tool), or for €50 more, buy it from Murena with e/os preinstalled.
There were some teething pains with the first few versions of e/os on the FP6, but now it's super stable.
The battery life is really good. On normal use for me (not a lot of video watching), I charge the phone every other day. They have a built in tracker blocker that works across all applications, which works really well. There's no data that leaves the phone unless you explicitly set it up.
It comes with Aurora store, which allows you to anonymously download playstore apps. Sometimes a install hangs or it cannot find an app, but to fix it you just request a new anonimos account by clicking logout and log back on. Takes 5 seconds. I mostly use F-Droid though.
The only cons we had (both my wife and I have an FP6), is cons that come with degoogled phones. Which is to say, some apps don't like it.
So far the only app I had issues with, was a museum pass app for my country. All my banking, government and work apps work fine. I run my work Microsoft apps in a container, so they cannot see anything on my phone, and cannot control anything on it either. And the bonus is, you can also turn off the container when you are done working. My wife had a weird issue based on her companies policies, that her work accounts did not work when she left the country. We're still trying to solve it. EDIT: Also the MS apps complain about Google play integrity, but we click on and the apps still work.
Also, if you want Android Auto, you have to install several google apps on the phone to make it work (there's a guide on the e/os website) But I think that defeats the purpose of a degoogled phone.
Ah, and their default launcher is terrible in my opinion. Looks like iOS. Do yourself a favor and install Lawnchair as a launcher.
Let me know if you have specific questions, or want me to test a specific app.
They could have made agreements with other manufacturers to releas the relock keys for older phones.
I hope Motorola and the whole damn android phone industry fights back because that's a whole new level of abuse of their position on the market.
I will NEVER have a phone with an OS that is locked and controlled by Google again. If my GrapheneOS device ever dies and there is no more GOS option available, I'm getting a Linux phone. I don't care if it isn't fully polished or fully functional yet. As long as it has the ability to make calls, handle text messages and use a web browser I can live with it.
I want to hold this line so bad, but damn. I hope Linux phones get a lot better very quickly....
I have used Sailfish OS a couple of months and couldn't be happier. G Haven't needed a Google account for anything.
Same, im really happy with my jolla phone and jollas support as well.
For anyone ootl, there was a production issue with one manufacturer where they didnt put in one component to protect the front camera from dust. Theyre offering to send everyone affected a new phone before expecting the defective one back, which is pretty awesome imo.
Same here. I put Sailfish OS on a Sony Xperia 10iii about a year and a half ago, and it's been great.
I just ordered a Commodore Callback 8020 as well. Way more than I usually spend on a phone, but I want a daily driver that isn't a full-fledged smartphone, as well as to support non-Google/non-Apple phone development.
Evil.
I bought a pixel explicitly for GrapheneOS. It will probably be the first and last I ever buy one. I hope Motorola is able to keep them developing.
I mean, Moto are, but the price tag sp far is quite literally Epstein Class. It's almost twice the price of a Pixel.
Yeah I was planning on getting one, but $1600 is stupid for what I use my phone for. I'll stick with my current phone and buy it used in a year or two. :p
There's only one flashable Motorola that you can buy new, and it's the Moto G15 4G that is probably the slowest phone you can buy. At least it's cheap.
They are talking about the Motorola and Graphene collaboration that is due in the future.
And it's about 10x more expensive than the G15.
Something in-between would be nice.
Very monopolistic behavior which, in a just world, would have them facing legal action to remedy it.
Too bad our world never has been and never will be just.
In the era of ~~identity~~ age verification and chat control we're far more likely to have legal action supporting it than against it
yes, but it would be a long drawn out legal battle because companies do have the right to refuse service to almost anyone for almost any reason in the US
mstdn.jp doesn't open for me, unfortunately. Hopefully, here is link to the same thread on official GOS mastodon instance:
https://grapheneos.social/@GrapheneOS/117645038299496084
