35
I've been struggling a lot recently about whether or not I should even go. If I'm there, I feel suffocated and unable to really be myself. If I'm not there, I feel like I'm abandoning my family and any opportunities I have to show my siblings that life outside of Christianity and heteronormativity is normal and beautiful.
I desperately want to be a good example, but anytime I'm around I end up feeling like a listless failure.
not partaking in any family gatherings is how I handle it, now in my case I was never a fan of family gatherings and always avoided them before, it also helps we have very few of them, of course not a good solution but it saves me a lot of headaches
Weird case as my parents were accepting of being trans but generally are not kind and have caused incredible trauma, so my experience is almost certainly different than others... But I did Christmas with found family instead.
In some ways, it was better, in others worse. But with a partner things can be especially better if their family is accepting.
Its a season of love, in one way or another... Be with loved ones who can love you too.
❤❤❤
I feel suffocated and unable to really be myself
show my siblings that life outside of Christianity and heteronormativity is normal and beautiful.
There may be a false dichotomy here. It can be possible to avoid the intolerance without cutting yourself off from tolerant family members, but you'll have to do your own kin-keeping. That's the work (usually unsung, usually performed by women) of planning, scheduling and inviting that creates and maintains these shared family bonds. It sounds like the kin-keepers in your family are unfortunately not accepting of you, or at least not willing to exclude intolerant relations from the invite list.
The kin-keepers in your family don't have a monopoly on kin-keeping. Anyone can do it! Now is as good a time as any to start making your own traditions. Host a holiday event, invite the people in your family that don't make you feel uncomfortable. Or if hosting isn't in the cards, coordinate holiday visits with the family members you do want to keep in touch with. Is it unfair that you need to do the extra work and spend the extra time? Of course! It's the same burden that's been placed on kin-keepers throughout history though, so at least you're in good company.
This should be its own post / stickied on every trans community on Lemmy. Great info / response homie.
i didn't realize there was a word for that! a fine new addition to my vocabulary :)
Oh I just don't go anymore.
Two years ago, I flat out told my mother I wasn't going to any holiday until she recognized my partner as my partner vs just "a friend". Got soooo many rude text messages that I ended up blocking her cell phone, my dad's cell phone, and her landline number so she couldn't contact me. (She uses my father's phone like it's hers and he can't push back because of his declining mental state).
Last year I made the mistake of going to a family get-together and halfway thru my mother had a meltdown because her feelings were hurt (she's a narcissist and attention whore) and I couldn't friggen leave because she was my ride and she was piss drunk and DEMANDED she drive home (we carpooled to save on gas).
This year she's already invited me, but because I've started presenting myself more femme vs masc, PLUS learning from last year's mistake, I'm just not going to attend. I know I'll get very rude comments from her and the rest of that shithole side of the family and I do not have the energy or motivation to deal with their crap.
I am organizing a local get-together dinner with my friends, loved ones, and people that I'm ACTUALLY bloody thankful to have in my life. It's way better.
Sorry to hear about this, you deserved / still do deserve better from the people who are biologically meant to be your ride-or-dies more than anybody else.
On the other hand, beyond glad to hear you’re accomplishing what I can only imagine OP will need to eventually do as well.
I hope you both can fill up all of these holidays that have effectively just been capitalist marketing tactics for basically the entirety of this millennium, at least thus far🤞.
I’m not in your situation, I just want to say that you wanting to go for your siblings is a beautiful act of love
On this note: try and make sure you keep open lines of communication with them. Narcissists, and for a lack of better words, evil people, love to use siblings as a means of control/punishment.
Theg can’t do that as easily if you’re nothing but their favorite sibling. Hell, the friction can ultimately lead to more general acceptance from the parents depending on how the cookies crumble.
Person with NPD here, I don't use siblings to control people. In fact, I don't control anyone who isn't in a BDSM relationship. And NPD is similar to a lot of other neurodivergences in that shortening the diagnosis into a label to put on people you don't like is... not something the community necessarily likes
i just dont go. i havent been to see family on the holidays in a few years and i feel pretty good about it. the people i really want to be around are generally doing some form of family holiday thing so its a nice time to be alone.
I don't go. The relatives who care about me know, and I moved far away so there's no real point in me traveling that far. You don't need to be an example to them. You don't have to change them. Being yourself is enough and if they can't see past their own beliefs to care about you as a person, then you cannot waste your time trying to be acceptable to them.
I just stopped going a couple years back. I’m not gonna spend my time going out of my way to see people that are just going to make me feel uncomfortable the whole time and wishing I was home.
It doesn’t feel great, but it’s better than the alternative
As someone who hasn’t gotten to hear this from my own family in a while: happy early and/or belated birthday to you BluJay320 😤🎉
And a happy early/belated birthday to you as well, dou9m
I do still get “happy insert holiday” texts/calls, which is nice I suppose, just don’t bother traveling
I don't have any room for people who don't have room to accept my existence. Spend time separately with your siblings or other family that is accepting. Doesn't need to be holidays. They're over rated and although a good chance to get a bunch together at the same time, not something you should need to feel bad about not participating in if there's no room for you to participate.
Friends and chosen family have been good for me on the day of, though honestly I don't really even celebrate that much. I actually ended up falling in with a Wiccan group which has more and separate holidays. I mean they do celebrate some of the holidays that the Christian ones ripped off of to ease conversion, like Yule is to Christmas, but we're actually mostly atheists, so it's not a theological religious thing, and mostly anticapitalists, so it's not about gifts. And were not the crystals and oils type "Wiccans" (who I've found are usually just about MLM cons).
The holidays are just a good excuse to get together and satisfy some tradition and ceremony kind of needs. I also appreciate we mostly spend time in nature during warmer holidays.
Anyway, not saying you should join another "religion", even if it's not theologically driven, but any group of like minded people who have regular gatherings is just nice to have and then the family holidays might not even be that important, especially if you can get the family members you still want to be around to come with you.
And even if you can't get the family members you want to be around into a group gathering and want something that still aligns with the Christian/your local country's holidays, just choose another day and get together with them on that day as a separate tradition.
Holidays are just on arbitrary days really. I mean it's not like Jesus was actually born on the modern December 25th (lots of evidence it wasn't winter much less aligned with our calendar at all) or the original American Thanksgiving was on the fourth Thursday of November since that was set recently enough to know when it was set to that date (1941). The calendars have changed so many times that it's very unlikely the date of any old holiday is perfectly right even if you don't want to believe that most of them were put on certain dates to either religiously convert people or to support modern capitalism's need for people to work consistent days rather than be a certain amount of productive.
I agree with you, although I must say that even with a separate support system, there is always gonna be an emotional void left by this kind of thing for most people.
On that note: I highly recommend some form of therapy with someone who ideally specializes in a mix of familial abuse, childhood PTSD, and/or trans/LGBT folks. Even just going twice a month can do wonders after a year or two, there’s a lot of repressed shit/self realizations/coping mechanisms that can take forever to come to by one’s self.
Yeah definitely is not a full replacement if you're used to strong family ties and big holiday gatherings. Personally, I lost that a long time ago unrelated to my transition. But I've always felt like having to do things on a certain day is silly and not worth stressing over if it's a few days before or after the actual holiday, and it's not worth exposing yourself to the pain of being treated as inhuman. Being treated that way is way more devastating, emotionally, not going. Seeing how they treat you up close and to your face and being stuck there having to take it is intense compared to just over the internet or whatever the rest of the days. But that's just me.
As a cis person who spent the last decade struggling because my family didn’t give a shit about me being abused by my dad, along with struggling with sexual/gender identity at the start of that time….
You very likely need to make your own support system, where most people have one by default with their biological family. I recommend going to cheap and good concerts (ideally both, lol)where you know the crowd will be LGBT friendly, personally. But also making good communities on social media can be a good start as well, I would’ve 100% killed myself in 2019 if it weren’t for multiple handfuls of people I’ve never met in-person giving me money to continue struggling to survive.
I’m so sorry that you are in this position, I do not wish it upon anyone but Nazis and “conservatives”, who in all reality should be the ones actually being exiled from their societies anf families
I skip a lot of holidays with my family, depending on my mood and mental resilience at the time. I plan to attend thanksgiving at my uncle's this year. It's a similar situation to yours, a mix of cool and extremely not-cool relatives. When I go I choose who I spend my time with, who I have conversations with, and which arguments I get drawn into, very carefully. Usually I have a good time with the cool relations and enjoy a mutually frosty detente with the others. I don't have unlimited rage energy but I don't mind showing the youngins how to stand up to bigotry and ignorance when the situation arises. Most of my family is non-confrontational to a fault, at least in group situations, so it rarely flares as dramatically as some families seem to, but it happens from time to time, especially as the liquor flows.
As I get older it's gotten easier to detect early and avoid if I so choose, partially by my own skill and partially because some of the worst offenders have died. But it's still all optional. I choose my family, and that includes the people who may or may not share more genes with me than others.
Can say only bout my imagination what would, as I'm not in such situation and probably never will be... so
At first, depends on previous experiences... then, depends how far it would be, how much travel would cost me - if few hours, maybe other part of same city - I'd go (maybe would try few times?), and be casually, daily, fem me. Show up as part of the family, gathering. If someone would push me away, kick out, would be on them. They would be the bad ones.
My morality would sleep well, knowing on my side, I've tried, did my best - to be casual self. Then, maybe them would see they got a loss.
At the day, unsure I could be brave enough to do, it could be big? That;s just my imagination here.
Hope none would have to go thru this.
<FLUFFY HUG>
I go to my in-laws, who are a bit stiff but polite. They do make me cute hats though. I hardly ever see them, so maybe they’ll be less stiff if I’m around more?
Honestly sounds like you’ve got the ideal scenario for most people lol, I’d probably agree w/ you about the less stiff if you saw them more part. Most humans suck at long distance relationships of any kind, because most humans currently alove have grown up in one of the most isolationist societies we’ve ever seen as a species.
I wish I could say it was the norm but I have never seem any statistics for this nor do I think they could ever be accurate when we’ve lost an unimaginable amount of the dataset to the opposition already 😞
Fuck 'em
