https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GUFVgi3p2Jk
it's like somebody making the dengist arguments in reverse
I made the joke that it's like they studied Xi Jinping's writing and stumbled ass backward into "capitalism with Chinese characteristics". NZ is about to accidentally reinvent socialism from first principles lmao.
Democracy isn't the problem. The problem is that China is democratic and the west isn't.
Not good. They just want to take the mask off, say China proved democracy doesn't work and we must now exist as serfs/slaves under the techno-feudal dictatorship of Thiel, Musk, and Bezos. They will continue on that just as in China they will kill your family if you disobey, that just as in China they will watch your every move, that not quite as in China but similar enough they will use kill-bots to enforce their will. And they will say this is necessary for "the west" to win, prosper, etc.
Stop reproducing, then they can't kill your kids. Having babies is cruel now.
Guy who believes all the bullshit anti-communist rhetoric but thinks that's cool and good:
That was me as a kid talking with other kids whose families immigrated over.
The kid would say Stalin didn't love his own children. Whacthu mean? Ooh Stalin didn't give concessions to the CIA in return for his son's safety? Wow what an honorable leader with integrity.
Oh in the USSR, they would shove a bunch of people into your apartment? Well where did they live before? If they had to be crammed into your apartment, doesn't that mean that were they homeless? Wow what a great country.
And the response was, "no, but in a bad way". I was like, hmmm.
"I mean, the Chinese have got centrally-managed capitalism. We don't have capitalism. America doesn't have capitalism. China has capitalism. Capitalism where you have brutal competition and they allow you to fail."
Actually Existing Capitalism
I gotta remember to take this stance with lib family members because I think it would actually be wildly effective
If large, vertically and horizontally integrated firms were the highest form of capital organization in the 19th & early 20th centuries, then it makes sense that it's evolution, the next stage of emerging organization, is New Deal style state ownership structure. Just because the United States had and then dismantled that system, doesn't mean it wont work for others.
Libs' mocking refrains of "that wasn't real communism" were projection all along.
Let him cook. His analysis is shit but let him cook.
Don't let him cook, or they'll create "National Communism" and say that China proved democracy doesn't work so give Elon and Thiel all the power.
Shit like this always feels to me like the groundwork being laid for the bourg to transition western "democracies" into just openly being everything they've spent decades telling us China was.
Most likely, but the material conditions won't change, pointless voting is one of the most important release valves for pressure on the working class, they remove that it won't magically make the working class more compliant.
I mean, it kinda sounds like a guy who's hiding his power level, but idk anything about him. Might be a broken clock chud.
Marx failed to foresee we might have to trick some of these ignorant mfers into communism for their own self preservation.
"Whatever you call it in China, at least it works" is not a bad starting point. It at least breaks someone out of the chauvinistic, Churchillian "sure our government sucks but we're still better than everything else."
Yeah, this will be the thing that really costs them legitimacy. The whole cold war, the claim was that the west was superior because we had "freedom" and "prosperity". Well, what now? Even for people who buy most of the anti-china propaganda, it's increasingly clear that their system is succeeding while ours is declining.
In western democracy, 90-97% of elected officials get reelected the next cycle.
In authoritarian China, about 27% keep their seats.
I do raise an eyebrow at the fact that only the lowest levels of representation are directly elected by the masses. I don't think the national legislature should be that insulated.
But at the same time, it's also the most populous country on earth, and the logistics of directly electing that would be fucking bonkers ¯_(ツ)_/¯
would love a reference for this to rub into the smug faces of libs
No less than the Cato institute which found that even in the early 2000s less than 20% of US elections were “competitive” in any meaningful sense.
https://www.cato.org/sites/cato.org/files/pubs/pdf/pa547.pdf
There is also Chinese discussion about “whole process democracy”, which can be framed as a critique of “western democracy” in that Chinese democracy is about local autonomy and delegating power over local affairs to the local level which elevates direct participation in democracy, in contrast to western democracy in which the candidate is first selected by the wealthy and politically connected elite, with the people simply presented a choice between two selected candidates - or in 80-90% of races actually not offered any choice at all.
local autonomy
Good point to bring up to anarchists too.
thank you, anything on the 27% number? didn't see any mention of China in the PDF
ooh this is interesting, do you have any material on this?
Bumping you for https://hexbear.net/comment/7618766
Thank you!
he's gon' die
Communist planned economy Wow, democracy is dead, this is real capitalism
I found a YouTube link in your post. Here are links to the same video on alternative frontends that protect your privacy:
