The California DMV has ordered Waymo to stop operating on state freeways, saying they "pose an imminent hazard to public safety."
Weird that the problems would occur on controlled-access freeways, the most constrained and predictable driving environment.
If by "weird", you mean "altogether expected, considering the whole thing's been criminally half-baked from the jump", then yep. 😅
No, I mean "weird" as in "I would've expected Waymos to be more dangerous on surface streets, with turning cars and pedestrians and whatnot." Self-driving on the freeway should be the computationally easy part.
Although now that I think about it, what I was about to write ("I would've expected them to be banned from surface streets first") wouldn't have made sense because they'd need to drive on those to get to the freeways anyway. Banning them from freeways is the only thing they could do short of banning them everywhere at once.
None of these “self driving taxis” are really self driving completely. In order to sell the illusion that they are, the companies remotely monitor and take over the operation of the car as needed when the software fucks up.
On surface streets at lower speed, this probably works fine. On a freeway things are moving too fast for a remote operator to really prevent issues from occurring, which is probably why they have more freeway incidents.
Waymo is closer to being three raccoons in a trench coat than it is to being a self driving taxi company
Important bit:
Riggs said data shows autonomous vehicles remain safer than human drivers overall.
The issue is really just a handful edge cases.
Uhh huh that's the problem not these companies refusing to take responsibility when accidents happen.
Where in the article did it say that Waymo refused to take responsibility?
Our ride-hailing service continues to operate safely on surface streets, serving over half a million trips each week. We are working with the California DMV and other state officials diligently and responsibly to resume freeway operations
Doesn't sound like a refusal to take responsibility.
If they accepted liability they'd never be able to operate as a business
They hit a tram last night and shut down a tram line. I'd put dollars to donuts that they will not pay for damages for it. Moreover I don't need the article to tell me the dreadfully obvious, it's been the biggest critique of self driving vehicles.
Got any sources on waymo shirking responsibility for crashes due to software errors?
I tried to find some, but everything I found said that they take responsibility for it if the investigation found they're at fault.
The problem is that the vast majority of crashes involving their vehicles were caused by human drivers.
There's about a half dozen current cases they are actively fighting from entering construction or delaying emergency services.
If they're found at fault which means they deny fault at first hence not taking responsibility.
They aren't. These specifically are self driving errors from not being able to navigate construction correctly which is distinctly not human error.
Buddy, the #1 advice for crashes is to never admit fault before the investigation makes its determination. That's just SOP in our shitty legal system. It's so common it's printed on my car insurance card. Hell, fighting it it's probably a requirement from their insurance.
What matters is if they keep denying responsibility after they're found to be at fault. Those were the cases I was unable to find.
Yeah that's generally I'm not at fault not "I'm not involved but I was in fact driving the vehicle".
Those would and are still in court.
Tell me which human goes to jail when a Waymo commits a crime for which a human driver would be sentenced to jail time.
Anything less than a human going to jail is a refusal to take responsibility. Unless Waymo's executives and/or licensed Professional Engineers are that confident that they would be willing to accept such liability, the product should not be on public roads.
Real engineers go to jail when their fuck-ups kill people. Waymo should be held to the same standard.
For every story like this there are a bunch of commenters shitting kittens. Show me Waymo vs. human accidents over X miles driven. I already know how that's gonna work out. :)
Yet people are blissfully unaware of America's 50K death toll on the roads.
Humans are so fucking awful at driving that the bar to clear is somewhere near the Earth's core.
But it's like this with any new technology. When I did the VDI rollout at my previous job, every software issue after claimed that it was only on VDI. When I actually asked the employees, every single time they said the issue was also present on regular PCs.
Spent 10-years as a sysadmin and more in tech support. I feel ya on this.
"You changed my oil and now my AC is broken!"
Umm...
Now, do the luxury car set! 🤌🏼
