cross-posted from: https://poptalk.scrubbles.tech/post/5072413
I definitely remember DVDs having autoplay trailers
Owning a physical media collection puts you only a couple hours a day for a few weeks away from having a personal streaming library.
Makemkv is the goat. I only wish it was open source, but given what the product does, I understand why it isn't.
I'm not a fan of 'piracy' per se, as in illegally downloading content from the internet. I'm an artist myself, I want other artists to get paid. But when it comes to the DMCA, ripping physical media I personally own, and streaming it to my own machines, from my own machines? RIAA and the MPA can eat my shorts. They're outta their goddamned minds if they're gonna think the digital ripping revolution brought on by the mass proliferation of the ipod is gonna end on my watch.
And all my friends say "no one uses CDs or DVDs any more".
Theres dozens of us.
More specifically hundreds of millions of us
Mmm not so sure. I would think in the entire world, the sum total of people regularly using their own media or DVDs etc as a norm is probably under 100k. And of those, theres probably a mixed use case of those who also stream.
Normies do not do this. They have phone. They stream. Thats it.
⛵⚓🛳🚢⚓
If people remembered what cable tv promised back in the day...
I heard about this growing up. Wild to see the exact same fucking rugpull in my lifetime.
I'm so glad I don't pay to watch ads. Fuck all of that noise.
I just borrow Blu-rays from my library and rip them for future use. It’s working out great!
Also, buy Blu-rays from thrift stores and rip them.
Libraries are getting rid of media too. Mine got rid of all their CDs. DVDs are next.
Sad times friends.
They aren’t all, my library continuously expands the Blu-ray and book sections. I have my access to 3 library systems and sometimes I borrow a bunch of movies and books, not to watch or read them, just to return them after a week or two so my library gets used ☺️
How cool!! Thats good. I was sad they did that here with CDs but holy crap the whole town came out to buy em all up it seems!
You could also just directly download from the web
Using your library supports the availability for everyone. I much prefer to borrow ebooks from my library and deDRM them, as opposed to downloading them from the various archives.
You can also rip the extras and set the quality exactly how you want it, instead of digging around for what might not be out there.
This is the way. Using your library confirms to local legislation that the library is being used. This helps to guarantee budget for your library, enhancing their collection and allowing them to stay open.
Yep! This is my reasoning as well.
And those DVDs also can have unskippale ads! But you can rip them.
Not only that, you have a legal right to rip media that you own. Sony overextended trying to get DeCSS declared illegal and it backfired on them massively.
I realized the other day that I’ve been pirating since high school, which is roughly 23-24 years or so now. Subscriptions can get royally fucked.
So, what, a few MBs total? 🙃
Cancels subscription because of forced ads
Puts in a DVD
Forced to watch ads before movie starts
At least you aren’t being stopped 4 times throughout the episode and can just fast forward or skip the intro ads on the disc
Pirates same movie
Launches Jellyfin
Watches in peace
Or just rip the disc you have.
This. I think a lot of people have forgotten that there were ads in DVDs. It also infuriated me back then.
I've been watching my DVDs through VLC for so long that I kinda forgot about all of the "unskippable" previews
But it is really fun seeing previews for terrible rightfully forgotten movies on 20 year old tapes and DVDs
But then we had chipped DVD players :-)
DVD's contained ads lol. Often harder to skip/edit out than vhs.
There's never really been a golden age of owning digital products. They've always been bundled with control and shit unless you pirate.
Handbrake takes care of that.
One important thing about physical media is that it doesn't disappear from your shelf when there's a rights dispute over 15 seconds of a song.
Makemkv does it better.
Just decrypts instead of re-encoding entirely. Uses less power than handbrake and runs a hell of a lot faster. Handbrake only gets added to my workflow when I'm downscaling to 480i for my CRTs (horror movies just feel better on a CRT in the bedroom than on the big flat 4k panel)
Probably. Handbrake is convenient enough for me and I'm happy with it.
You can easily skip past the unskippable ads when using a software DVD player like VLC. When you rip the DVD, you can rip just the movie and not have to skip anything.
Just remember that bypassing any copy right protections (like you do when ripping your bought physical media) is still considered illegal...so why even bother with the physical copy in the first place.
Yar, ye be what now?
I think they're more like guidelines than actual rules...
If ye be understanding me, savvy?
Parley? Parley
Just remember that bypassing any copy right protections (like you do when ripping your bought physical media) is still considered illegal
That sounds like something that is entirely region-dependent
Not when you're doing it to "back up your own media".
It depends on the region actually. it's almost always allowed to backup your own physical media, but at the same time not allowed to bypass copyright protections to do it. So if you can't rip the media without bypassing the copyright protection, it's actually illegal to make a digital backup. It's absolutely nuts.
VLC does the same thing, so watching a DVD/Bluray with VLC is illegal too in some countries.
I don't think there is any legal way to watch DVDs/Blurays on Linux at all.
Yes that depends on the country, I think it's not even equal EU wide. In Belgium we're allowed to rip DVDs and other physical media we own for personal use, including circumventing the DRM. The same law makes us pay a levy on all storage devices to compensate copyright holders. So it'd be a waste not to.
that was at some point the case due to proprietary software pieces. but i think that got resolved by now. haven't checked in years.
No, making backups of media that you own is fair use. I'm pretty sure this was all tested in the courts during the VHS days, but I could be wrong.
Making a digital backup is only legal if you can do it without circumventing the copyright protection on the medium you're backing up from. It's not the backup itself that's illegal, it's the circumventing of copyright right protection methods that's illegal.
And is there precedent for this? Or is it just speculative and never tested in court?
Well it's written specifically that you cannot circumvent copyright protection technology to copy media in the law text where I live so...
I understand you're saying that's what's in the law, I'm not even questioning that.
But until the law is tested in court, it's all hypothetical. And if it hasn't been tested in court, there's likely a reason for that. Because precedent cuts both ways and the corporations with a stake in it know they could lose.
I'm not a legal scholar, but I feel like something like this could really go either way in court, depending on which lawyers, judges, etc. are involved.
Personally, I think they're correct to have avoided officially taking someone to court over this. Because it would probably backfire for them.
No way!? Let me guess: land of the free?
Nope, EU...
Legal to do in the US to "backup your own media".
Exactly. And ads before the movie, whatever, skip em - I would still download a car, but whatever. But advertising DURING a movie or TV show you have paid to own/rent? Never on physical release: no such physical commercial release ever existed AFAIK.
Yes, much like VHS if you use a tool to override the intended presentation you get a different one.
I am not sure what your point is. DVDs still suck unless you rip them. They are an anti-user product.
I remember in high school I would download anime that wasn't released in the states and create my own DVDs with menus and everything to sell to other students. It was a wild time for bootleg media. But I wouldn't have any ads on anything.
I did orders from an import shop for anime snacks to go with the DVDs I made, good times.
this can't be true my disney+ tier through jellyfin has no ads.
So strange. None on my NovaPlayer SMB, Stremio or MeTube downloads either.
We must be doing something wrong.
Wild I also have no ads on my jellyfin Disney/Netflix/prime/HBO/Hulu/apple/sports/literally every other network. What a great deal
did you run a fucking screenshot of a tweet through chatgpt? what the hell is wrong with this?
Don't forget that some DVDs can fail as soon as 20 years after printing and some Blu-Rays within 10. Keep your physical copy, but consider ripping them as well.
I thought that many movies these days are not even making it to DVD/BR. I remeber the good old days in ASDA choosing which DVD i would buy ...
The first Ad I see will have me cancelling my plan...my extended family will be devastated.
Morpheme. I've had add supported for free from internet provider only started watching it when morphe came out.
y'Arr.
(Son)Arr. (Rad)Arr. (Lid)Arr. (Prowl)Arr.
This. The *Arr stack is a godsend nowadays, especially if you have access to quality private trackers.
ARRs in Usenet
But yes. That stack is amazing
I've been collecting DVDs for the last 2-3 years when I realized one of my favorite shows was split between a free platform with ads and a paid platform. I cancelled all other platforms (at the time was Prime, Netflix, and YouTube Premium) and have went back to shopping for new and used DVDs.
For anyone actually doing this, let me know when you find a BluRay player that'll actually play blurays. Just bought a Panasonic 420 and the drive started grinding after 3 movies.
Playstation 3s are actually amazing as Blu-ray players.
Yup! I have an old PS4 that is strictly used as a Blu-ray player now
Consoles.
👆🏻
I never actually watch physical discs.
MakeMKV works a treat to rip all my media.
Edit. Which is then hosted on a "server" (2019 Dell Small form factor desktop, or an old laptop) and stream via Jellyfin. Or DLNA which pretty much any smart TV supports.
I bought a Panasonic DMP-BD90P-K at Walmart and I watched almost the whole series "Legend of Korra", no issues
As others have said, PlayStations aren't bad for it. And they have dedicated remotes to make them more like a regular user would expect.
I have a few standalone bluray players I bought at a surplus auction from a university. Ones they used to keep in the classrooms or av hall or whatever. They seem to just work. They are the most bare ones devices and remotes. But they were cheap (free since they came with other av gear I actually wanted in that lot.)
I've got an Xbox One that's been going pretty hard for BluRays, have had an issue or two with regular DVD, but it might be a problem with those specific discs. Now of you're looking for a USB BluRay player, I usually check LG for those.
Normies never understanding copyright, and DVD copy protections, will never not be funny.
Enjoy 20 years of DVD ads!
