Amends (2018-05-23)
(midwest.social)
(midwest.social)
Man, he was a hell of a hunter but a pretty sub par soldier from the looks of that line.
I like to believe this is implying he also ate that guy
Like that worst timeline Marvel story where Captain America introduced Nick Fury to the sweet sweet taste of long pork during Vietnam?
I've already made peace with the lives I've taken and will take to secure my own survival. Talk to any of those pigs and they'd do the same thing.
So was he like a rancher or a slaughterhouse worker after the war?
There’s an elephant in the background. Most likely he was a poacher I guess
Think it's meant to be some comment on eating meat.
Do we have to make peace with each bacteria individually or can we do it collectively?
Or the wasp nest we wiped out
Plants?
Our own cells?
humanity breeds and consumes like billions of chickens at a rapid pace, right?
i wonder how many trillions of them are crowding heaven.
Soo, is the point of the comic veganism or was he a really efficent hunter?
Because if it's veganism...where the fuck are the people that got exploited to make your phone, your clothing etc etc?
Cut this crap please
Considering there is a whole swarm of flies/mosquitoes I think the comic is deeper than just another one of those mischievous veganism posts.
Interesting way to blame individuals for capitalism.
Pretty sure people have been eating meat long before capitalism.
See my other comments in this thread
Capitalism sold you meat. That didn’t occur in a vacuum. We were eating meat before capitalism was involved.
Do you think most people today would go slaughter their own animals for food if the other option was picking up vegetables and other easy options at the store? Most people don't have the stomach or tools to kill a cow, chicken, or pig and prep it.
I think that's more a side effect of people largely not living an agrarian lifestyle anymore since folks literally did that for thousands of years. Though you often times did also just get s butcher for larger animals since they were professional and often did it in exchange for a share.
I can't legally keep my own chickens where I live, otherwise I would.
I had to put down my rabbit, I had to crush my pet spider under my heel. I sure as hell can take out a chicken that I've raised explicitly to be food, and if I can't... Well, my wife grew up on a micro farm, where they raised their own cows and chickens, she definitely can slaughter an animal and butcher a carcass.
I said most because I know there are still many out there like yourself; seems like you'd one of the exceptions to the rule. Even then, I'd think the amount of meat you consume would be cut down by a noticable degree.
Yes.
When did capitalism force you to eat meat? You did it because you wanted to.
When did capitalism make me personally kill those animals?
By eating them you demand for them to be killed.
I am not judging you for that, if you want to eat meat then you can. But stop trying to blame someone else for your own actions.
By wearing clothing you demand for children to be enslaved and to die at an early age. By driving you demand for the middle easterners to be killed. By owning anything made of wood you demand the Amazon to be clearcut. By drinking coffee you demand women are killed. By eating a banana you demand South Americans are brutalized to death. This is your logic applied in full.
Clothes and cars are a bit complicated since they are often essential, and the more ethical options are more expensive so not everyone can afford them. I'd still say those who could buy the more ethical options ought to do so.
Meat and coffee are resource intensive goods with cheaper alternatives which cause way less suffering.
So yes, paying people to mistreat humans without need is cruel. Paying people to brutalize animals to death is cruel too. One logically can't justify the other.
Where have we gone wrong that people always feel the need to argue for putting animals into literal death camps, of all things? I just wish people would strive to make the world a less cruel place for once, but that is just too much to ask for in this society.
paying people to mistreat humans without need is cruel. Paying people to brutalize animals to death is cruel too.
almost no one does this though. a few people do.
It's not too much to ask for a kinder society, but asking doesn't make it one. The only way we stop mass animal cruelty is through revolution against our capitalist oppressors that make commodities of living things. I look forward to when we can live in a society that can systemically reject it.
personally meat that's been tenderized through animal cruelty is the whole point!
you can't imagine how hard I get while gnawing on a thick juicy steak. sometimes I'll even use the juice from the meat as lube when I fuck tomorrow's roast and blast ropes into the creamy center. it's even better when I stuff some warm veal up my asshole.
since most cabbageheads want to make normal everyday eaters into monsters, I'll play the villain you made up in your mind.
There is literally no way to eat meat (i guess lab grown but that's very recent, though arguably might be further developed if not capitalism) that doesn't involve killing an animal. It's not capitalism. The horrible living conditions somewhat are, but still nothing is forcing you to eat meat at all.
And yes by buying ultra cheap clothing you're demanding labor exploitatipn. Probably the biggest difference with meat though is that it's not even more expensive to not eat it lol. Buying meat from animals that actually had a decent life is, but that's not the only option.
I eat meat myself but your argument just doesn't hold.
Buying any commodity is exploitation. As soon as we have a world where meat isn't a commodity, then yes you are correct, but until then it doesn't.
I would say that that's more if those products are bought new. The moneyless Buy Nothing sub-economy/movement helps a lot.
I think the fact is that most of the things you listed are true, to a certain extent, though you do not carry the sole burden of every chicken. (And in the context of the comic, the specific species there imply that he was an avid hunter and did, literally take the lives of those creatures himself. He was, perhaps, also a farmer.)
There is "no ethical consumption under capitalism" and "the only way to live a life free of sin is not to live at all" (sin here defined as "actions causing negative externalities"). Every action has consequences, but I think it's just about understanding that we do carry some culpability for the far-reaching consequences of our actions. Trying to minimize those with the resources we can afford should be a touchstone for all of us. We probably shouldn't be buying a bunch of chocolate, not only because the vast majority of chocolate is FULL of DEEPLY unsafe levels of lead and cadmium, but also because much of it is produced with slave labor.
However, the person hounding you above needs to see to their own house. If they are so high and mighty as to try to shame you, (which, make no mistake, they were absolutely doing despite their claim to the contrary) then it is they, not you, who should be ashamed.
When it comes to how you eat, many vegans claim moral superiority because they have the privilege of time and resources to be able to afford a vegan lifestyle. Most of them respond that all it takes is switching to plant protein and buying fruits and veggies, but then they conveniently leave out that not everyone has the luxury of time necessary to perform proper meal preparation for their families. I'm a pescetarian, and I believe that I have to be mindful of the systems I support by continuing to live... Full stop. I don't need to shame a bunch of people to make my own choices seem more holy. It seems like the commenter above thinks they do. We are, all of us, part of systems of exploitation. What we need is education, so that we all understand the systems in which we take part, so that we can grasp which systems are necessary (for now), which can be replaced, and from which we might cut ourselves loose to end them. You have clearly already been educated on these systems, so that dude lecturing you serves no purpose save their own self-aggrandisement
So it is true that we contribute some small part to the demand for meat when we purchase it but, to quote my favourite book: "You have to do whatever you can't not do".
If that means considering the moral effects of every choice, then you must do so. If that means trying desperately to survive in a world run by Corpocratic Christofascists bent on the subjugation of all life for their sole benefit, then you have to do what you must to live.
The exact same number of animals will die today whether or not I choose to have a burger for dinner. This is not something within an individual's control. If you want this to change, it has to happen at societal level.
I am not judging you for that
you seem to be using some pretty heated phrasing that states otherwise...
I saw it more as a vegan thing but I follow
That's also blaming individuals for capitalisms crimes.
"Don't you get it?! I was forced by the CEO of Nestlé himself to consume brutally killed animals. I am just a little girl who can't do anything at all."
I don't see how an individual eating meat is capitalism, but I'm sure someone will try to explain it poorly
We are talking about the comic. This person didn't personally kill all those animals, someone else did. Sure he benefitted from it, but that doesn't make him the killer. If we operated on that logic, he's killed millions of global south people as well. Where are they? Are their lives somehow not worth mentioning?
Yeah, like a few for things you can't really avoid then maybe. But no one is forcing you to eat steak.
The bones are their dollars
finally someone who gets it
Other economic systems also eat meat.
Oh no, just imagine the black cloud of mosquitos
Do I get to kill the ants a second time?
Fuckin hate ants, always tryin eat my hair
I don't recall us accidentally eating them, or vice-versa?
Bonus pts for the upcoming Screw-worm epidemic...
Do you think the Vietnamese guy was eaten?
Probably Japanese considering the bow
Hard to say considering the amount of East Asian people the USA shot at.
there's an elephant in the room
Wait, so I get to talk and cuddle a bunch of chickens, cows, and pigs? That doesn’t sound so bad. I’d be happy to make amends with them. I’d love to see what they’d have to say about the industrial food complex.
The thing about asking forgiveness and making amends that people tend to forget is that you have to actually regret it. If you're just like "sorry I killed you, but you were delicious!" you're not really making amends.
I've got a friend trying desperately to teach their toddler that biting someone while apologizing for biting them doesn't prevent them from getting in trouble.
That toddler is ripe to join the political class!
I taught my two-year-old to say sorry, but he says it in the most sassy and amused way possible.
I'm sure the local pigherder thinks I'm crazy but I love meeting their piglets. Then I go get a nice breakfast with extra bacon. It's like getting sushi after visiting the aquarium.
Honestly, more people should meet their meat like this.
He sure killed a lot of animals.
Yeah, so did you and every living person. Most don't kill by their own hand but absolutely through their lifestyle (eating meat, using anything with animal products in it, anything that affects the habitat of any animal etc.).
Ah, right, christianity and their sinner by extension shtick.
Don't get me wrong; you should eat less meat. For your own and the planets health.
Why are you saying "you" and not "we?" Are you somehow exempt from all this? I notice you're saying "their" and not "our." Why are you distancing yourself (even when you acknowledged "every living person")? This kind of divisiveness does not help sway people over. We need to work as teams, not opponents, to enact healthy societal change.
Automatically, based on how we normalize and produce all that.
I mean, was he a butcher or something?
He didn't have to get his hands dirty. Others did it for him, aided by plenty of automation, breeding, and cruel farming systems.
Then why is there only one human there? What about the thousands of people who have died working in unsafe and unclean conditions to produce clothing, electronics, and the like for first world countries? I’m vicariously guilty for the deaths related to every burger I’ve eaten, but not for the iPhone I’m typing this on?
You seem to be taking things pretty hard for some reason. This is just a piece of dark humor, and maybe a thought-experiment / point of reflection. Nobody is trying to lay a guilt-trip on you, AFAIK.

Matrix chat room: https://matrix.to/#/#midwestsociallemmy:matrix.org
Communities from our friends:
LiberaPay link: https://liberapay.com/seahorse